“That’s actually the top of the case for Wright Prospecting,” he stated.
“With nice respect, it’s all slightly determined … looking for one thing that reveals the partnership was within the enterprise of constructing main mining infrastructure when all of the proof factors on the contrary, and that’s backed by Michael Wright’s sworn proof.
“I’ve stated it earlier than, and I’ll say it once more, this case is only one of remorse by those that run Wright Prospecting, who remorse not becoming a member of Lang in growing the very helpful Hope Downs undertaking.”
And the Hope Downs tenements weren’t the property of Rinehart’s Hancock Prospecting both, Withers informed the court docket.
Withers insisted the choice to shift the tenements to separate firm automobiles inside the household belief was one made by Lang as controlling thoughts of Hancock Prospecting as a result of he wished his 4 grandchildren to obtain the complete financial profit these property have been set to yield.
He stated Rinehart then got here alongside after Lang’s dying and took the property again unlawfully regardless of being abreast of the plans for his property, refuting Hancock Prospecting’s declare the preliminary switch was a breach of fiduciary responsibility.
Withers informed the court docket the opposite events’ instances have been constantly altering and contorting, hailing his authorized staff as the one ones who had offered an easy model of the tenements’ possession historical past.
Loading
And he additionally refuted claims swathes of his shoppers’ case hinged solely on a court docket rule whereby it was inferred that Rinehart’s determination to not take the stand was as a result of it might not have helped her case.
“Gina was flatly towards the thought of Hancock Prospecting turning into a mining firm, and the proof reveals that Gina stated in no unsure phrases that she didn’t need something to do with [Lang’s plan] to promote ore to Romania,” Withers stated.
“If Gina’s opposition had prevailed, Hancock Prospecting would by no means have these tenements.”
The youngsters’s closing submissions are anticipated to run till Thursday earlier than reply submissions start on December 4.
Justice Jennifer Smith is anticipated handy down a call in mid-2024.
The Morning Version e-newsletter is our information to the day’s most essential and fascinating tales, evaluation and insights. Join right here.