Denley: Townhouse plan reveals metropolis’s incoherent social housing strategy

Article content material

Ottawa Group Housing’s choice to spend $86 million on a plan that acquires no internet new reasonably priced housing items appears daft on first examination. Town-owned social housing group’s preliminary makes an attempt to justify the expenditure did nothing to contradict that impression.

Let’s face it, shopping for 311 aged Nepean townhouses that have already got reasonably priced rents, for that type of cash, will not be an concept that sells itself.

Article content material

Article content material

OCH instructed that if it had not acquired the items from Minto House REIT, another person may have purchased them and raised the rents. “This acquisition safeguards 311 houses from market hypothesis,” OCH mentioned in a press launch. It’s a rationale that might be utilized to the acquisition of just about any rental unit within the metropolis.

OCH additionally claimed that the deal “helps with the present lack of reasonably priced housing in our metropolis.” Possibly, however within the brief time period all it does is give the individuals renting the townhouses a brand new landlord. The 12,000 individuals ready for government-subsidized housing will hold ready.

An inexpensive individual might need anticipated an in depth OCH report explaining why the seemingly unhealthy deal was truly a clever expenditure of cash. Such a report would reply some primary questions. For instance, how will the deal be funded? What are the annual financing and working prices? How does that evaluate to anticipated rents from the items?

One group of townhouses was inbuilt 1969, the opposite in 1975. At a mean price of $276,000 a unit, the brand new acquisitions are low-cost, however what sort of restore legal responsibility is OCH endeavor?

Article content material

OCH declined to reply these particular questions or to launch a report till Feb. 15, the day the deal closes. The housing company cited “adherence to established enterprise protocols and confidentiality measures.” What would these be? OCH launched the common unit worth and Minto House REIT has put out appreciable element on what it means to its enterprise. There had been non-disclosure agreements in place throughout negotiations, however these are over.

It appeared that OCH was falling again on the more and more widespread principle that how the general public’s cash is spent is absolutely not one of the public’s enterprise. If solely OCH had been as economical with cash as it’s with data.

And but, after extra inquiries, OCH lastly produced a senior employees member who may provide a rationale for the $86-million expenditure. Whereas most rents for the Nepean townhouses are thought of reasonably priced now, even with out an possession change they’re already going up sharply when tenants vacate, says OCH chief growth officer Cliff Youdale. OCH possession will forestall that.

Youdale says the rents the townhouses generate will likely be ample to cowl financing and working prices, making the newly acquired townhouses self-sustaining. There’s some restore work to be performed, however the low promoting worth displays that.

Article content material

That’s the plan, with none supporting numbers. Little doubt OCH will likely be helped by the truth that new items will not pay property tax, as OCH items are exempt. That may deprive Ottawa of about $1 million a yr in income, based mostly on metropolis numbers.

One may say the townhouse plan is rational, at the least by the requirements of the federal government social housing world, a particular zone the place rationality will not be predominant, nor even anticipated.

With regards to spending on sponsored housing, something goes, whether or not it’s pouring cash into previous townhouses which can be already reasonably priced or spending it to purchase fancy items within the new Zibi growth, then subsidizing them so we will faux they’re reasonably priced.

Let’s be sincere. Authorities-owned housing is a public legal responsibility and the extra of it there’s, the larger the legal responsibility. Each aspect of the system depends on a authorities subsidy and it goes on in perpetuity.

For many who consider that is smart, any type of social housing plan is totally justified just because it’s a social housing plan. Maybe they might do the remainder of us the courtesy of explaining why in a well timed approach, with details and numbers.

Randall Denley is an Ottawa political commentator and creator. Contact him at randalldenley1@gmail.com

Article content material