The Belgian Presidency of the Council of the EU has circulated a brand new draft textual content of the platform work directive, which needs to be the idea for technical negotiations amongst member states on Tuesday (16 January), amid persistent divisions in regards to the directive’s scope.
The draft textual content, dated 10 January and seen by Euractiv, virtually completely matches the provisional settlement discovered in interinstitutional negotiations – generally known as ‘trilogues’ – on 13 December.
On 22 December, nevertheless, the exact same settlement was knocked down by a majority of member states, who thought of that the Spanish Council presidency had overstepped its mandate within the negotiations.
The platform work directive seeks to make sure employees of digital platforms equivalent to Deliveroo and Uber have the right contractual standing based mostly on their remedy and dealing circumstances. The laws additionally units new bold provisions on algorithmic administration within the office.
In a canopy word connected to the brand new textual content, the Belgian presidency says it’s dedicated to putting a deal earlier than legislative work ends and EU election campaigning begins.
Since time is of the essence, the provisional settlement, “though as such not acceptable to a majority of member states, must function foundation for additional negotiation”.
Belgium has requested member states to touch upon this new iteration of the textual content with a view to informing “a [new] proposal for a revised mandate to Coreper”, the Committee of Everlasting Representatives that gathers EU ambassadors, the duvet word reads.
France, in a word seen by Euractiv, has already warned it couldn’t agree to make use of the trilogue’s provisional settlement as a place to begin and has referred to as on the Belgian presidency to stay as shut as attainable to the Council’s mandate.
Whereas the nation holding the rotating presidency of the Council ought to play the function of the trustworthy dealer, each Belgium and Spain have been pushing for a extra prescriptive method with stronger safety for employees.
In contrast, France, the Nordics, and Central Japanese European International locations have been pushing for a extra versatile method that may pose much less necessities on platforms.
Authorized presumption standards
The brand new textual content hones in on the authorized presumption of employment, the directive’s flagship mechanism by means of which self-employed platform employees may very well be reclassified as full-time staff based mostly on their working relationship with digital platforms.
The Fee’s preliminary proposal stipulated that the presumption may very well be triggered if two out of 5 standards which trace at subordination have been met. The Council elevated the brink to a few standards out of seven, whereas the Parliament’s authentic stance was to take away the standards altogether and deal with the precise working circumstances.
In the long run, the provisional settlement settled on a 2/5 cut up – however essentially the most reticent nations complained that the wording of every criterion was so broad it may virtually systematically be met.
To deal with such issues, contemporary wording has been added.
The primary two standards stay unchanged from the Spanish deal and deal with remuneration dedication and work efficiency supervision.
The subsequent three, nevertheless, focus particularly on whether or not a digital labour platform “restricts the liberty” to organise one’s work by means of accepting or refusing duties, imposing working hours, and affecting employees’ discretion to make use of subcontractors in the event that they so want – considerably decreasing the scope of the presumption altogether in comparison with the December deal.
“The symptoms [i.e. criteria] also needs to comprise concrete parts displaying that the digital labour platform intently supervises the efficiency of labor, additionally by completely verifying the standard of the outcomes of the work of individuals performing platform work,” the recitals learn.
Nonetheless, “the standards shouldn’t cowl conditions the place the individuals performing platform work are real self-employed”.
This comes amid France’s, and several other different member states, issues that the directive because it stands runs the chance of resulting in a blanket reclassification and failing to guard the ‘genuinely’ self-employed.
[Edited by Luca Bertuzzi/Zoran Radosavljevic]
Learn extra with Euractiv
