Baftas 2024 evaluation: A really British reminder that 2023 was extra than simply Barbenheimer

Get our free weekly e mail for all the newest cinematic information from our movie critic Clarisse Loughrey

Get our The Life Cinematic e mail without spending a dime

Ultimately yr’s Baftas, plenty of issues occurred: a two-hour-and-a-half German-language movie gained Greatest Image; Irish actors swept the supporting classes; and a Californian heartthrob picked up the Greatest Actor award for taking part in a Mississippian heartthrob. These moments, nevertheless, have been virtually completely erased in our collective reminiscence in favour of a brief rap interval by which Ariana DeBose relayed how Angela Bassett “did the factor”. It was the kind of cringe-inducing viral section that no stay occasion can confect, or actually aspire to. So, a yr on, the query is: how does the buttoned-up Baftas comply with that viral second in awards present historical past? Or would the flicks, finally, be allowed to do the speaking?

“Tonight goes to go smoother than Ken’s chest,” host David Tennant introduced on the off, his kilt someway fluttering within the airless ambiance of the Royal Pageant Corridor. Tennant is a type of actors who’s an A-lister on his residence turf, however solely identified internationally to the neighborhood of nerds that comply with Physician Who or Harry Potter. He has by no means finished a Marvel film, nor has he had a sniff of an Oscar nomination himself. He’s extra small display than large display; extra The Workplace than Field Workplace. And but he has the innate charisma essential to straddle the road between comedian emcee and trade advocate. As a bunch, he’s within the mould of David Niven, who carried out proceedings on the Oscars 3 times between 1958 and 1974: suave, cheeky however, most significantly, a secure pair of fingers.

That stated, the Baftas, in its present broadcast kind, is a wierd beast. “Even I don’t know who’s gained,” Tennant instructed his assembled viewers throughout his opening monologue, which was unusual provided that I used to be receiving BBC push notifications saying that Cillian Murphy and Emma Stone had simply taken the highest appearing gongs. The choice to air the ceremony following an approximate two-hour delay (and after social media turns into ablaze with information of the winners) cuts all the stress from proceedings. It nixes the opportunity of the kind of spontaneous chaos – Warren Beatty and Faye Dunaway screwing up the Greatest Image announcement or Will Smith forcibly eradicating his spouse’s identify from Chris Rock’s mouth – which have typified the Oscars lately. Whereas that makes the present really feel much less pressing, it additionally permits the Bafta bosses to elide among the (politely talking) much less public-facing awards, like Greatest Sound or Greatest Animated Quick. Their speeches are edited into punchy little packages; the orchestra by no means as soon as required to play winners off stage.

All the identical, it begs the query of what precisely the purpose of the Baftas is. You see, the taxonomy of awards exhibits is actually this: the Golden Globes is the place the actors get drunk, the Oscars is the place they genuinely care; and the Baftas is the place the glamour of proceedings is interspersed with baffling references to British subcultures. (This yr’s iteration alone featured Sophie Ellis-Bextor performing her 2001 hit “Homicide on the Dancefloor” and Ted Lasso’s Nick Mohammed roller-skating onstage in character, for some motive, as Mr Swallow.)

The In Memoriam section – at all times a possibility for one thing a bit mad – featured one other Ted Lasso forged member, Hannah Waddingham, warbling “Time After Time” – although she missed a trick by omitting “Ariana DeBose’s profession” within the record of lately deceased. Presenters of awards ranged from glittering superstars like Cate Blanchett and Idris Elba, to bookings like Andy Serkis or Adjoa Andoh, who’re unlikely to get the identical gig on the Dolby Theatre subsequent month.

That is the nub of the Bafta’s attract: managing to be profoundly parochial with out making it too apparent. It’s because the smooth energy of British movie star is considered one of our most beneficial exports (alongside overpaid footballers and monetary companies) and the duty of the Baftas, due to this fact, is to make British celebrities look like essentially the most fabulously well-known, essential, and proficient folks on this planet, all with out drawing explicit consideration to the truth that they’re British.

The Oscars this yr are brief on homegrown expertise (simply Carey Mulligan and Emily Blunt are repping on the appearing entrance), however the Baftas felt like an explosion of home creativity, from Christopher Nolan and Samantha Morton, to The way to Have Intercourse and Earth Mama. And viewers on BBC One had been handled to a celebration of movies that broke the mould. “I used to be positive I wasn’t going to win,” Twine Jefferson instructed the group, receiving his gong for writing American Fiction. “We’re very shocked,” the producer of The Zone of Curiosity instructed the group after beating Poor Issues and Saltburn to Greatest British Movie. “Shocked.”

The Baftas is a needed reminder, to British audiences, of the existence of movies exterior of the Marvel world or the Star Wars universe. It is necessary that 2023 (a fantastically sturdy yr for cinema, within the context of the previous decade) is remembered for extra than simply Barbenheimer and Barry Keoghan’s penis. The Baftas this yr had been an incredible indication of that. It could all really feel a bit neat and sanitised – and admittedly, a lot is misplaced by stripping out the stay dimension – however for an trade that wants eyeballs, this was an excellent commercial.