Within the wake of the farmers’ protests, the German authorities tried to pin the blame on supermarkets, however now the German Monopolies Fee has concluded that there are certainly imbalances, though it warns towards hasty political selections.
Financial system Minister Robert Habeck (Greens) tasked the nation’s Monopolies Fee with analysing the meals chain for imbalances in market energy. For the German Inexperienced social gathering, it’s not the EU’s environmental proposals which are in charge for the farmers’ precarious state of affairs however the dominant pricing behaviour of meals retailers.
A preliminary report by the Monopolies Fee concluded that “the buildings of the meals provide chain in Germany present indicators of potential points by way of competitors and of market energy.”
Nevertheless, the advisory physique explicitly warned towards hasty political reactions.
“Particular rules exist already immediately that smaller producers of agricultural merchandise can use to strengthen their bargaining energy,” Jürgen Kühling, chair of the Monopolies Fee, informed Euractiv.
He urged warning, nonetheless, saying that “these prospects naturally carry dangers, corresponding to agricultural companies that aren’t concerned being squeezed out of the market.”
Utilise current alternatives first
The preliminary report recommends that “interventions in agricultural markets or meals provide chains to strengthen the market place of farmers ought to solely be undertaken cautiously and on a transparent factual foundation.”
The market buildings ought to first be completely analysed to evaluate the danger of undesirable distortions of competitors, additionally to the detriment of farmers.
When asserting the investigation, German Agriculture Minister Cem Özdemir wished to overview unused EU rules – corresponding to Article 148 of the EU’s Frequent Market Organisation (CMO), which might introduce a contractual obligation for uncooked milk deliveries.
Though this could give dairy farmers planning safety, in line with the MEG Milch Board, it could solely apply to round 30% of them, as the bulk are organised as cooperatives, and the regulation wouldn’t apply to them.
Different accessible measures can be “For instance, numerous types of cooperation within the manufacturing and advertising and marketing of agricultural merchandise that aren’t permitted in different sectors,” says Kühling.
Initially of the 12 months, farmers in Germany took to the streets to protest towards a deliberate lower in diesel subsidies that may trigger them monetary hardship, blocking a number of motorways and metropolis centres. This culminated in a rally of 30,000 farmers and 5,000 tractors in Berlin in January.
Nevertheless, the federal government noticed little room for manoeuvre to again away from the deliberate cuts, as financial savings within the federal price range have been essential to plug a €17 billion hole within the price range after the Constitutional Courtroom declared the proposed price range unconstitutional.
Different approaches have been subsequently sought to assist the agricultural sector, with elements of the federal government fast in charge the pricing insurance policies of grocery store chains.
The German Farmers’ Affiliation (DBV) didn’t touch upon utilizing the already accessible possibility regardless of being requested a number of instances by Euractiv.
Preliminary investigation
The Monopolies Fee’s report factors out that “as a result of extremely internationally organised provide chains and the widespread organisation of agricultural markets by the EU,” such discussions wouldn’t solely have an effect on Germany, as related issues additionally have an effect on different European nations.
The issue of purchaser market energy within the meals chain shouldn’t be new. “There may be now a broad consensus in financial analysis that meals markets are sometimes not absolutely functioning aggressive markets,” the report reads.
In Germany, there has “traditionally been a excessive stage of market focus within the meals retail sector, which has elevated additional since 2011. In some instances, excessive market concentrations will also be seen on the processing stage.”
A take a look at the farmers additionally reveals that the share “of gross sales income from finish merchandise has fallen steadily in current many years.”
“General, even based mostly on this preliminary evaluation of the meals provide chain, potential indications of current market energy could be recognized, which may very well be to the detriment of farmers.”
Subsequent steps
The Monopolies Fee itself sees enough proof of market energy throughout the provide chain to warrant a extra in-depth investigation deliberate for early 2025. It’s also contemplating “recommending a sector inquiry by the Federal Competitors Authority”, in line with the report.
Based on the Federal Ministry for Financial Affairs and Vitality (BMWK), additional steps are being mentioned in shut dialogue with numerous gamers within the meals provide chain. The purpose is to look at “whether or not and, if that’s the case, the place there’s a want for authorized changes,” a BMWK spokesperson informed Euractiv.
[Edited by Oliver Noyan/Angelo Di Mambro/Alice Taylor]
Learn extra with Euractiv
