B.C. lady sentenced to 4 years for manslaughter in demise of son

Article content material

A Port Alberni lady convicted of manslaughter within the taking pictures demise of her grownup son two years in the past has been sentenced to 4 years in jail.

Samantha Dittmer, 64, was initially charged with the second-degree homicide of Jesse McPhee, a 37-year-old longshoreman who was shot and killed at point-blank vary with a looking rifle of their shared residence on Aug. 29, 2021. In October, after a four-week trial, a jury convicted Dittmer of the lesser offence of manslaughter primarily based on her careless use of a firearm.

Article content material

Article content material

At her sentencing listening to Friday, Dittmer informed the courtroom she was devastated that her son was useless.

“The trauma I felt watching my son die in entrance of my eyes is insufferable,” she mentioned. “And I’m so sorry that occurred. … If I may take all of it again I might. Nobody goes to overlook him greater than me. I’m very very unhappy.”

Each Crown and defence requested for the four-year jail sentence, which is the obligatory minimal sentence for the offence of manslaughter dedicated with a firearm.

Justice Margot Fleming mentioned though she didn’t think about Dittmer to be a reputable witness, she believes Dittmer didn’t intend to kill her son. Based mostly on the proof, Fleming was glad that Dittmer dedicated the illegal act of careless use of a firearm. She discovered that Dittmer’s dealing with of the rifle was objectively harmful and a big contributing reason for McPhee’s demise.

The trial heard that Dittmer moved to Port Alberni from the Decrease Mainland a number of years in the past. She deliberate to promote her home in Tsawwassen the place McPhee was dwelling together with his spouse and two younger kids and have everybody dwell along with her.

Article content material

Article content material

Nevertheless, McPhee and his spouse went via a bitter and painful separation. There have been arson makes an attempt on the house in Tsawwassen and McPhee was overwhelmed up and injured. Finally, he and his new associate, Brandy Kazakoff, moved to Port Alberni, and lived on the primary flooring of Dittmer’s home.

Dittmer and her son had been nonetheless fearful for his or her security and arrange safety cameras. McPhee had a number of firearms and a big quantity of ammunition. He insisted on placing the rifle upstairs underneath his mom’s mattress in case of an assault. Dittmer had a tough thought the way to use the firearm. She knew it had a security and knew it had ammunition within the buttstock.

The trial heard that McPhee was attempting to show his mom self-defence. He would sneak up behind her and slide his thumbnail throughout her throat, which she discovered unnerving. In the summertime of 2021, McPhee was violent, erratic and by no means sober.

McPhee was not ready to deal with his separation and was utterly depending on his mom. Because of this, Dittmer was extraordinarily pressured and unwell. She had dangerously hypertension and was experiencing panic assaults. Her physician referred her to Port Alberni psychological well being.

Article content material

On Aug. 29, 2021, Dittmer, Kazakoff and McPhee went to Nice Central Lake to examine on crayfish traps. McPhee drank a variety of beer. The ladies had been additionally ingesting.

Again at residence, Dittmer was pressured and requested her son for a hug. McPhee hugged her so arduous he damage her and whispered in her ear that perhaps he ought to simply put her out of her distress.

Dittmer was appalled and left the home, the trial heard. Whereas she was out, she determined she needed McPhee to take the rifle from underneath her mattress and put all his weapons away.

Returning residence, she grabbed the rifle with out doing any security checks and walked downstairs into McPhee’s suite. He was standing there trying away. Dittmer determined to place rifle down and stroll away quietly.

“Impulsively, there was some sort of bodily contact between Mr. McPhee and Miss Dittmer brought on by him all of the sudden speeding in direction of her. The rifle discharged throughout this contact, the muzzle pushing or urgent in opposition to his chest. He was shot and landed face down on the ground,” Fleming mentioned.

An post-mortem discovered that McPhee’s blood alcohol degree was two-and-a-half occasions the authorized restrict.

Article content material

Though Dittmer testified that she by no means had her finger on the set off, Fleming mentioned she was glad past an affordable doubt that Dittmer brought about the rifle to fireplace by pulling the set off by accident throughout the sudden bodily contact with McPhee.

“He couldn’t have pulled the set off. The set off needed to be pulled. And her proof denying she pulled the set off is totally unreliable. Her reminiscence may be very poor, fragmented and considerably inconsistent,” Fleming mentioned.

The quantity of pressure to tug the set off was slightly below 4 kilos, she famous.

Though McPhee was not functioning properly, his violent demise is a tragic loss to those that knew and cherished him, together with his two daughters, his step-sister and his mom.

“He was not solely troubled, he was passionately alive, loving and really artistic,” mentioned Fleming.

Though Dittmer spoke about how a lot she cherished her son and by no means meant to hurt him, she didn’t take duty or specific regret for the taking pictures, mentioned the choose. Quite, Dittmer mentioned: “If folks assume I used to be careless as a result of I didn’t assume it was loaded, properly, I suppose I used to be.”

The choose discovered Dittmer’s ethical blameworthiness was decreased by her emotional and psychological misery.

Bookmark our web site and help our journalism: Don’t miss the information it’s good to know — add VancouverSun.com and TheProvince.com to your bookmarks and join our newsletters right here.

It’s also possible to help our journalism by changing into a digital subscriber: For simply $14 a month, you may get limitless entry to The Vancouver Solar, The Province, Nationwide Publish and 13 different Canadian information websites. Assist us by subscribing right now: The Vancouver Solar | The Province.

Article content material