Breakenridge: Let’s be sincere about what’s behind transgender coverage

Article content material

There was a time final yr when the most important difficulty on the tradition struggle entrance was the matter of drag performers studying kids’s books to children at native public libraries. There have been intense protests in opposition to these occasions in quite a few cities — so intense, actually, that Calgary crafted a bylaw particularly to maintain these protests at a better distance from the libraries.

Article content material

No matter ethical or spiritual objections these protesters had, calling on such occasions to be prohibited may be very a lot a case of “authorities is aware of finest.” If the idea of “parental rights” had entered the controversy, it clearly would have utilized to not the protesters however to these mother and father who selected to attend with their very own kids. Nobody else was compelled to attend.

Article content material

There’s an fascinating and noteworthy overlap between those that noticed match to oppose the alternatives of different mother and father and those that have now positioned themselves as champions and enthusiastic supporters of parental rights. Possibly this actually isn’t about parental rights in any respect.

This all considerations Alberta’s sweeping new gender identification coverage, which one cupboard minister bluntly described as a selection between parental rights and authorities is aware of finest. Actually, nobody in authorities opposed drag studying occasions, nor wouldn’t it be truthful to accuse each proponent of this new coverage of holding such views. However even inside the confines of this coverage, there may be an inherent contradiction between a want to reinforce parental rights and selections that erode it.

Article content material

Article content material

Because it pertains to high school, this very a lot will increase the involvement of fogeys. There will probably be a brand new opt-in coverage for any sex-ed curriculum or dialogue of sexuality or gender points, which means that oldsters should first approve their little one’s participation. And, after all, there will probably be obligatory parental consent or notification if a scholar needs to be referred to by a unique identify or pronoun.

But, in the case of medical therapies and interventions for transgendered youth, the federal government is muscling in on territory at present occupied by mother and father. Whereas mother and father had been beforehand those to have the ultimate say — at the side of docs — on such interventions, the province is now taking that call out of their palms via new age limits and restrictions.

Article content material

There’s a cheap dialogue available round age-appropriate materials in colleges or the extent to which oldsters must be made conscious of sure points. It could even be cheap to have a look at the parameters across the aforementioned therapies and interventions, and whether or not there’s a must proceed extra cautiously in these areas.

However these usually are not, strictly talking, parental-rights points. If that was the principle underlying thrust of this entire dialog, we’d be listening to far more pushback from the ostensible proponents of parental rights in regards to the areas the place it’s being chipped away.

The federal government is simply as responsible of this double customary. They’re those who designed this coverage and are attempting to have it each methods. The premier lately took a swipe at “anybody who’s making an attempt to place roadblocks in that child-parent relationship,” and but one of many specific goals of her personal coverage is to create these roadblocks.

In fact, all of us perceive the significance of the child-parent relationship, and that makes the entire idea of “parental rights” sound very interesting. In any case, who would argue that oldsters shouldn’t have rights?

Article content material

It’s all very paying homage to the “household values” politics of the Nineties. Households are necessary, as are values, however “household values” was extra a few branding train for a extra ardent type of social conservatism.

There are clearly social conservatives who’ve their fingerprints on Alberta’s new coverage, along with these loudly supporting it (together with one outstanding group who celebrated this as a “large blow to transgender ideology”).

Let’s simply attempt to be a little bit extra sincere about that truth.

“Afternoons with Rob Breakenridge” airs weekdays from 12:30 to three p.m. on QR Calgary

rob.breakenridge@corusent.com

Twitter: @RobBreakenridge

Article content material