Welcome to Euractiv’s Tech Temporary, your weekly replace on all issues digital within the EU. You may subscribe to the e-newsletter right here.
“The EU might, due to this fact, have an vital function in offering focused help to twin use, on the pathway from R&D to deployment, proper by way of to market uptake or public procurement.”
-Draft White Paper on choices for enhancing help for analysis and improvement involving applied sciences with dual-use potential
Story of the week: The European Fee will current three choices for enhancing R&D on dual-use know-how, in keeping with an early draft of a white paper seen by Euractiv. The intent is to interrupt the silos between civilian analysis programmes like Horizon Europe and the military-focused European Defence Fund. The choices entail rising cross-fertilisation by sustaining the present authorized setting unchanged, introducing the chance for particular components of the following Horizon Europe to work on defence-related issues, or creating a selected instrument for dual-use R&D. The white paper might be offered on 24 January as a part of the Financial Safety Bundle that will even embrace communication on financial safety, a assessment of the International Direct Investments Regulation, a white paper on export controls, a brand new initiative on outbound investments, and Council draft suggestions on analysis safety. The juiciest half is about to be on export management, the place the Fee is because of introduce cloud and Synthetic Intelligence within the present export controls regime, in what appears to be a response to the mapping of non-American cloud customers that the US administration has kicked off following the Govt Order on AI. Euractiv understands that the Fee wouldn’t essentially must amend Annex I of the Export Management Regulation, as non-listed objects may very well be topic to an authorisation regime on the nationwide. In different phrases, the Fee might change the widespread evaluation standards, giving nationwide authorities the facility to resolve whether or not cloud or AI applied sciences may very well be used for navy functions.
Don’t miss: France’s ‘influencer legislation’ is designed to focus on these from outdoors the European Union; due to this fact, aligning the legislation with EU guidelines won’t be an issue, Stéphane Vojetta, the rapporteur of the legislation, advised Euractiv. The European Fee despatched a letter to the French authorities in August 2023, two months after its enactment, contemplating it contradicted some EU single market guidelines. “For now, the most important concern stems from influencers who migrate to Dubai to evade taxes and, from there, interact in deceptive, fraudulent, and unlawful promoting regarding French and European legal guidelines,” Vojetta advised Euractiv. As such, the French lawmaker believes adapting the brand new legislation to the Fee’s demand might be simple. Learn extra.
Additionally this week:
- Stakeholders don’t see why they need to signal the Fee’s cookie pledges.
- The EU may make a U-turn to incorporate the personal sector within the Council of Europe’s AI Conference.
- Gatekeepers’ rivals complain they don’t seem to be being consulted on DMA compliance.
- The Belgian presidency shared (not so) new textual content on the Platform Employees Directive.
- The Council detailed in a sequence of case research how EU nations implement the ePrivacy Derogation.
Earlier than we begin: Should you simply can’t get sufficient tech evaluation, tune in on our weekly podcast.
AdTech
Pledges with out signatories? The EU Fee shared a revised model of the cookie pledges on Monday (15 January) with some aesthetic adjustments and included the EDPB’s opinion, giving the members till 7 February to offer additional feedback. The personal actors concerned stay considerably sceptical of the proposed ideas, elevating considerations across the truth all kinds of monitoring are put in the identical basket, even once they serve completely different functions, the disintermediation threat for publishers in a situation the place person preferences are centralised on the net browser degree and the restricted involvement of advertisers within the dialogue. Most significantly, stakeholders don’t see any profit in signing up, as pledges wouldn’t present a presumption of compliance with present guidelines just like the GDPR, as is usually the case with these voluntary initiatives. If potential, the brand new draft makes this even worse because the preamble states that “voluntary pledging to the beneath ideas doesn’t take away the necessity for a case-by-case evaluation.”
Synthetic Intelligence
EU’s U-turn on AI conference? Following the data notice on the Council of Europe’s AI Conference negotiations, the EU may make a U-turn relating to retaining the personal sector within the scope. In a Telecom Working Social gathering assembly final Thursday, most member states pressured the necessity to attain a worldwide settlement (i.e. together with the USA). Therefore, the Fee shouldn’t insist on together with personal firms. Such a limitation to the treaty’s scope would imply a major setback for the Fee’s ambition to make use of the AI Conference to set the AI Act because the worldwide benchmark. As well as, to align the treaty with EU laws, the EU is pushing for a similar nationwide safety and legislation enforcement exemptions. Limiting the primary worldwide treaty to public our bodies, with the addition of those broad carveouts, would make it not well worth the paper it’s written on. The ultimate determination is anticipated on the plenary assembly subsequent week.
Dutch imaginative and prescient on gen AI. The Dutch authorities offered their imaginative and prescient on generative AI on Thursday, emphasising the urgency of performing whereas contemplating the know-how’s alternatives and challenges. The imaginative and prescient additionally discusses tens of millions of euros value of investments by analysis establishments, personal enterprises, and the federal government. The purpose of the investments is to maintain up with the developments in AI. “We’re unwilling to depart the long run socioeconomic safety of the Netherlands solely within the palms of main tech firms,” mentioned Minister for Digitalisation Alexandra van Huffelen.
In the meantime, in Davos. To take care of on-line integrity in an election-heavy yr world wide, tech leaders gathered in Davos debated on Tuesday night the latest rise of AI and its implications for deceptive campaigns and misleading content material within the ballot run-up. On the similar time, Microsoft’s CEO, Satya Nadella, defended its partnership with OpenAI. “If we wish competitors in AI in opposition to gamers who’re vertically built-in, I believe partnership is one avenue of, in actual fact, having competitors,” Satya Nadella advised Bloomberg in an interview in Davos. Learn extra.
EU supercomputers. The European Fee and the European Excessive-Efficiency Computing Joint Enterprise opened their entry to EU supercomputers to hurry up AI improvement, in addition to to SMEs, as a part of the EU AI Begin-Up Initiative, it was introduced on Tuesday.
OpenAI-Pentagon collab. OpenAI and the Pentagon are working collectively on a number of initiatives touching upon cybersecurity as effectively, which fits in opposition to the startup’s earlier ban on offering AI to militaries.
IMF Employees Dialogue Observe. The Worldwide Financial Fund printed a Employees Dialogue Observe about generative AI on Sunday, mentioning, amongst different issues, some constant patterns within the matter, akin to ladies and college-educated people being extra uncovered to AI however are additionally higher geared up to reap its advantages.
LLM customisation. Standford College’s Human-Centered Synthetic Intelligence identified, in a examine dated January 2024, the protection dangers coming from customising basis fashions by way of fine-tuning. The doc’s key takeaways embrace that enormous language mannequin (LLM) builders more and more permit customers to customize the pertained fashions by way of fine-tuning and that regardless that mitigation methods are additionally rising, no present one can assure to forestall dangerous mannequin customisation.
GenAI session. The UK’s Data Commissioner’s Workplace printed its session on Monday about how information safety legislation ought to apply to creating and utilizing generative AI fashions. ICO identified that an applicable authorized foundation for coaching these techniques was among the many questions that emerged by way of its engagement with innovators. The session is open till 1 March.
Competitors
Fee to step into the vacuum. Amazon’s merger with iRobot, the corporate making sensible vacuums, is anticipated to be blocked by the EU antitrust regulator as a result of harming the competitors within the vacuum market, in keeping with Bloomberg. Nonetheless, the choice shouldn’t be remaining but, as formal approval is but to come back by February 14.
Intel set to win? Advocate Normal Laila Medina sided with Intel on Thursday in its ongoing authorized battle with the EU about an antitrust wonderful of €1.06 billion, which was record-high when it was given. Based on the courtroom advisor, flipping the win within the decrease courtroom wouldn’t work because it didn’t point out that Intel abused its dominance within the PC chips market.
Web neutrality and competitors. Throughout the plenary classes on Tuesday, the competitors coverage stories have been adopted, together with the modification, which provides that “attracting funding and securing telecom infrastructure and innovation” needs to be achieved with out compromising web neutrality.
Copyright
Music streaming decision adopted. The European Parliament requested for guidelines regarding the music streaming sector, ensuring it’s honest and sustainable and promotes cultural variety. MEPs need the imbalance in income allocation from the music-streaming market to be addressed within the adopted decision as a result of low compensation for artists.
Cybersecurity
Army cybersecurity. On Wednesday on the Nationwide Meeting, two French MPs offered their navy cybersecurity suggestions to their colleagues, constructing on the French place on procurement, cloud, and useful resource sovereignty. Learn extra.
Brussels Summit. The Belgian presidency organised its Cybersecurity Summit on Thursday and Friday. Whereas the Fee known as for the swift implementation of NIS2, in casual talks, nationwide officers and CSIRT specialists complained concerning the implementation time and steady piling up of latest guidelines on the EU degree, making clear a couple of nations might be late within the transposition. Furthermore, IMEC offered information displaying that whereas AI techniques for intrusion detection have an nearly excellent accuracy price within the lab, in the true world the accuracy drops at 15%.
Bleu launched. Capgemini and Orange introduced their joint future “cloud de confiance” platform known as Bleu on Monday. Bleu is at the moment partaking with chosen French private and non-private organisations, making ready for the migration. The primary companies will go stay on the finish of 2024.
Information & Privateness
Bracing for the EDPS race. By November, the EU Council and Parliament should agree on the brand new European Information Safety Supervisor based mostly on a shortlist supplied by the Fee. The incumbent, Wojciech Wiewiórowski, is operating once more and is at the moment the strongest candidate, as he can depend on a beneficial change of presidency in Poland. The one different confirmed candidate is the Bulgarian Ventsislav Karadjov, who runs for each publish on the EU degree. Somebody from CNIL can be mentioned to affix the race.
GDPR enforcement. Justice Commissioner Didier Reynders advised POLITICO on Wednesday that central European-level enforcement of the EU’s Normal Information Safety Regulation (GDPR), much like the Digital Companies Act and the Digital Markets Act, could be anticipated.
Eleven nations are nonetheless match to deal with EU private information. The Fee determined on Monday to resume the adequation selections of 11 nations earlier than the GDPR, contemplating they proceed to profit from enough information safety safeguards. Due to this fact, EU private information will be despatched to those nations “with out further necessities, ” supporting private information industrial agreements between the block and these nations. Andorra, Argentina, Faroe Islands, Guernsey, Isle of Man, Israel, Jersey, New Zealand, Switzerland and Uruguay are on the listing. Canada’s allowance solely considerations industrial operators.
€10 million in cookies. French watchdog CNIL made public on Thursday that it issued a €10 million wonderful on the finish of December in opposition to Yahoo for violations of the ePrivacy Directive. When utilizing Yahoo!, 20 promoting cookies would nonetheless collect information regardless that a person wouldn’t consent. Furthermore, when a person withdrew consent from cookie information gathering on Yahoo! Mail, the corporate used phrases to chorus from customers’ decisions.
DPO report. On Wednesday, the European Information Safety Board printed its report on the Designation and Place of Information Safety Officers (DPOs). The survey’s outcomes emphasise “the necessity to strengthen the function and recognition of DPOs – and the necessity to proceed selling the significance of the DPO’s function”.
Digital diplomacy
TTC summit scheduled. The subsequent EU-US Commerce and Know-how Summit has been confirmed on 30 January. It won’t be a full ministerial, within the sense that there won’t be a joint assertion on the finish because the concept is to progress on what has been beforehand introduced to arrange the groundwork for the final summit in April. Progress is anticipated within the AI roadmap, standard-setting on quantum computing, digital ID and 3D printing, information-sharing on semiconductor subsidies, a standard analysis agenda on 6G, and information entry for researchers.
Germany and Japan in digital dialogue. On Tuesday, Germany’s digital minister, Volker Wissing, met together with his Japanese counterpart, Taro Kono, for a bilateral trade. Subjects of debate included an enough regulatory framework for AI and the metaverse, making certain free information flows by decreasing paperwork, and the upcoming G7 summit scheduled for the top of April.
Digital Markets Act
Massive tech rivals not happy. With 50 days to the compliance of the Digital Markets Act’s deadline of 6 March, a number of rival firms are ringing the alarm bells regarding the gatekeepers’ ‘lack of efficient engagement’, asking them to provoke a constructive dialogue with enterprise customers and client organisations. Learn extra.
Holding it linked – or not. Google will now provide European customers the selection of whether or not they wish to preserve Google companies linked, together with Search, YouTube, Advert companies, Google Play, Chrome, Google Buying, and Google Maps”. The person decisions will take impact on 7 March.
DMA implementation report. The Centre on Regulation in Europe (CERRE) shared a publication on Wednesday concerning the substantive and procedural ideas of implementing the DMA.
Digital Companies Act
Dashing into X? Based on an EU official, the Fee’s probe in opposition to X was rushed beneath political stress from Thierry Breton, who needed to point out his muscle tissue forward of the European elections. Essential components of the DSA are nonetheless to be totally outlined, and a hasty begin dangers placing the EU government within the place of constructing a weak case, particularly because it should show in courtroom breaches akin to insufficient content material moderation or threat mitigation measures, for which there’s nonetheless no case legislation.
Getting ready for elections. The members of the EU Code of Apply on Disinformation are establishing a kind of speedy response mechanism that ought to present a construction for data sharing about their threat mitigation measures all through the electoral course of. Nonetheless, very massive on-line platforms are considerably restricted in what they’ll share as a result of any piece of data may very well be used in opposition to them to show non-compliance with the DSA. One other perverse impact of the DSA is that, because the Fee can now request inner paperwork, tech firms are excited about not launching inner investigations – at the very least not till the compliance staff asks for it. In the meantime, the Code’s practitioners have arrange a subgroup on generative AI that has rapidly develop into the most important one, the place stakeholders share the dangers of those techniques and their potential, for example, in flagging suspicious content material to fact-checkers.
Recruiting at full velocity. The Fee has opened 40 job alternatives within the DSA staff. 4 profiles are required: authorized officer, information scientist or know-how specialist, coverage specialist, and operations specialist.
I want extra data. On Thursday, the Fee despatched out requests for data to 17 of the 22 systemic platforms beneath the DSA. They’re now anticipated to offer data on the measures taken to adjust to the DSA by 9 February 2024.
Czechs not prepared. Lower than a month earlier than the deadline to arrange a Digital Companies Coordinator, the Czech Telecommunications Workplace nonetheless wants workers and the mandatory laws to make sure it fulfils its duties. Though the division is meant to have 18 workers to take care of this agenda, the CTU says it solely has 4. Learn extra.
Gig economic system
Again at work. After a failed try at getting the platform work directive over the road, the file is again on the negotiations desk. The Belgium presidency circulated a brand new textual content, nearly an identical to the provisional settlement present in interinstitutional negotiations – ‘trilogues’ – again in mid-December, bar tweaks to the wording of the authorized presumption of employment’s standards. At a Working Social gathering assembly on Tuesday, nationwide delegates famous “vital adjustments” to the employment standing chapter, by way of “the authorized presumption stays the primary level of competition”. The Belgian presidency will share a brand new textual content forward of an ambassadors’ assembly on 24 January.
Industrial technique
Atos continues prime reorganisation. Atos publicised on Monday that it will not meet its Q2 2023 money movement targets and proceeded to varied adjustments within the prime managing staff. Paul Saleh, present CFO, turned CEO, whereas a brand new CFO and a number of other new administrators have been appointed. Saleh’s predominant activity might be to refinance Atos’s monetary money owed, additionally by way of the sale of its Tech Basis line of operations to Czech-owned EP Fairness Funding (EPEI), for which the Fee gave a inexperienced mild final month.
Institutional nook
Fee priorities. On Tuesday, the EU’s prime digital coverage bureaucrat, Roberto Viola, offered the Fee’s precedence for the following six months, specializing in finalising the AI Act and concluding the interinstitutional settlement on the Gigabit Infrastructure Act. The Fee intends to concern an innovation package deal by the top of January. It would concern a white paper on coverage choices for future telecom laws by the top of February. Viola mentioned the EU ought to make speedy progress in innovation if it’s not to lose its lead and pushed nations to keep up a single market method.
EPP manifesto. A draft electoral manifesto of the European Folks’s Social gathering (EPP), dated 12 January and seen by Euractiv, suggests reducing down on “EU paperwork” in essential coverage areas akin to tech, stating “we wish to allow, develop, and utilise AI, not comprise it or hinder it”. The doc additionally talks about defending offline and on-line residents, storing IP addresses for all probably the most extreme felony offences, and making cyberbullying a felony offence. The get together thinks a European cyber brigade with clear exterior and inner safety obligations is required.
Legislation enforcement
CSAM case research. An inner Council doc, seen by Euractiv, illustrated how EU nations are implementing the momentary regulation aiming to forestall on-line little one sexual abuse materials, detailing how the invoice is already getting used to catch suspected content material. Learn extra.
Interim regulation replace. Based on a draft report concerning the interim regulation of the CSAM draft legislation by the EU Parliament’s Committee on Civil Liberties, dated Wednesday and seen by Euractiv, the interim regulation’s timeline might change once more and expire on 3 Might 2025, anticipating it from the unique 3 August 2026. Based mostly on the amendments, number-independent interpersonal communications service suppliers should publish and submit stories to the competent supervisory authority of the Fee.
Media
EMFA COREPER adoption. EU ambassadors adopted the European Media Freedom Act with the only opposition of Hungary. France and Italy made declarations regarding nationwide safety and felony investigations. The Fee issued a written declaration to make clear that media legislation doesn’t goal to harmonise key ideas of felony process or outline competent nationwide authorities.
Platforms
Macron’s display screen time campaign. Throughout a Tuesday press convention on the Élysée Palace, French President Emmanuel Macron proposed new guidelines for reducing youth display screen time to forestall spreading conspiracy theories on-line. The French President introduced that the federal government will resolve on potential “prohibitions” and “restrictions” for underage folks based mostly on a fee of specialists’ report that might be delivered in March. Learn extra.
Digital worlds vote. Throughout Wednesday’s plenary session, MEPs voted on the digital worlds report of the Authorized Affairs Committee, addressing its authorized and coverage implications, with the ultimate model being adopted in a single vote. MEPs need the EU to guide in shaping digital worlds whereas respecting EU values and making use of present legal guidelines.
Telecom
DNA as per Chips Act. On Monday, Inner Market Commissioner Breton defined throughout a tour in Paris that the upcoming Digital Networks Act will observe the identical construction because the Chips Act. “Look at how [the Chips Act] is structured, and I imagine we will redeploy it precisely as it’s,” Breton defined. He continued explaining that telecom deregulation or fair proportion debates are previously, whereas Europe ought to set a imaginative and prescient for the long run.
What else we’re studying this week:
Quantum Computer systems May Rework Monetary Markets, Says BOE (Bloomberg)
Google DeepMind’s new AI system can clear up complicated geometry issues (MIT Know-how Evaluation)
Spotify assaults Apple’s ‘outrageous’ 27% fee (BBC)
Alina Clasen and Théophane Hartmann contributed to the reporting.
[Edited by Alice Taylor]
Learn extra with Euractiv
