Ilan Troen, a Brandeis College professor emeritus, at his house in Omer, Israel. His daughter and son-in-law, Deborah and Shlomi Mathias, had been killed within the Hamas assault on Oct. 7, 2023.
Tamir Kalifa for NPR
cover caption
toggle caption
Tamir Kalifa for NPR
Ilan Troen, a Brandeis College professor emeritus, at his house in Omer, Israel. His daughter and son-in-law, Deborah and Shlomi Mathias, had been killed within the Hamas assault on Oct. 7, 2023.
Tamir Kalifa for NPR
OMER, Israel — 100 days in the past, on Oct. 7, American-Israeli historian Ilan Troen stood over his 16-year-old grandson’s hospital mattress. The bullet that killed his daughter had pierced his grandson’s stomach.
I discovered Troen within the hospital carrying a Brandeis College t-shirt. He was one in all my professors after I studied there.
Three months later, I visited his house in Israel’s southern desert, the place he’s now retired, to listen to his reflections — as a historian and bereaved guardian — about Israel’s deadliest day in historical past, and the deadliest struggle that Palestinians have ever confronted, nonetheless ongoing in Gaza.
A basso continuo of disappointment
”How am I?” Troen asks, on his lounge sofa. ”In Baroque music, there’s one thing known as the basso continuo. In the event you take heed to Bach, there’s that backside line that continues, and my basso continuo is one in all disappointment.”
Music was his daughter and son-in-law’s life. Deborah and Shlomi Mathias had been singers who met in music college.
On Oct. 7, attackers from Gaza stormed their house and blew down the door of their bolstered protected room. The mother and father protected their son, Rotem, with their our bodies, saving his life as they misplaced theirs.
Pictures of Deborah and Shlomi Mathias with their three youngsters are displayed at Deborah’s mother and father’ house in Omer, Israel.
Tamir Kalifa for NPR
cover caption
toggle caption
Tamir Kalifa for NPR
Pictures of Deborah and Shlomi Mathias with their three youngsters are displayed at Deborah’s mother and father’ house in Omer, Israel.
Tamir Kalifa for NPR
Burying them of their house group enveloped in struggle, Kibbutz Holit close to the Gaza border, was out of the query. As an alternative, the household wrestled with one other query: what to write down on their gravestones.
”It was the kids who determined that they might not placed on their mother and father’ headstone what another folks have finished…’could God avenge their blood.’ They needed nothing of that,” Troen says.
As an alternative, their three youngsters inscribed the gravestones with musical notes: the opening bars of Brit Olam, or ”Eternal Covenant,” a basic Israeli love tune that Deborah, who glided by the Hebrew title Shahar, had sung with Shlomi at their very own wedding ceremony.
”It is a method of claiming that the years to come back…they won’t give attention to the tragic,” Troen says, ”However reasonably on the sweetness of their lives.”
Caring for his or her orphaned grandchildren
Rotem, Troen’s 16-year-old grandson who survived the Oct. 7 assault, got here to stick with his grandparents Ilan and Carol after he was launched from the hospital. A day later, Carol was at her lounge desk when he screamed from the opposite room.
”Simply screaming, ’Why? Why? Why? It is not truthful, it is not truthful, it is not truthful,'” Carol says. ”And I screamed again, ’Why? Why? Why?’ As a result of I needed to reply him…I simply screamed with him.”
Carol Troen at her house in Omer, Israel. Her daughter and son-in-law, Deborah and Shlomi Mathias, had been killed within the Hamas assault on October 7.
Tamir Kalifa for NPR
cover caption
toggle caption
Tamir Kalifa for NPR
Carol Troen at her house in Omer, Israel. Her daughter and son-in-law, Deborah and Shlomi Mathias, had been killed within the Hamas assault on October 7.
Tamir Kalifa for NPR
The day I visited the Troens, their grandson was maybe in search of solutions. He was visiting his house in Kibbutz Holit for the primary time since he was attacked inside it. Carol was boiling soup on the range for her three orphaned grandkids. An Israeli warplane roared above.
”It is on its solution to Gaza,” Troen stated.
”Perhaps she would perceive”
Greater than 23,000 Palestinians, largely girls and youngsters, have been killed in Gaza within the Israeli bombardment, in accordance with well being officers there. The struggle got here after Hamas led an ambush on Oct. 7 that killed some 1,200 folks in southern Israel, in accordance with Israeli officers.
Now the struggle has reached a crescendo on the world stage. Israel stands accused of genocide on the Worldwide Courtroom of Justice.
”Crimes towards humanity? We had been defending ourselves,” Troen says. ”This is not vengeance. That is safety. Self-defense.”
Ilan Troen shows a photograph from 1975 of his household on the land the place they constructed their house in Omer, Israel. Within the picture, Troen holds his daughter Deborah when she was younger. She was killed Oct. 7, 2023.
Tamir Kalifa for NPR
cover caption
toggle caption
Tamir Kalifa for NPR
Ilan Troen shows a photograph from 1975 of his household on the land the place they constructed their house in Omer, Israel. Within the picture, Troen holds his daughter Deborah when she was younger. She was killed Oct. 7, 2023.
Tamir Kalifa for NPR
His daughter Deborah believed in the opportunity of peace together with her neighbors. She despatched her youngsters to Hagar, a uncommon elementary college in Israel’s south, the place Jewish and Arab children research collectively. I requested Troen what his daughter may take into consideration the best way Israel is waging its struggle in Gaza and its excessive human toll.
”I believe she could be appalled and anxious, perhaps offended, however perhaps she would perceive,” he says. ”If of a greater method, kindly inform us, what (is) the higher, cleaner, nicer method of coping with the form of menace that we have now to face, that has frequently risen to attain its final divinely-inspired and commanded objective of exterminating us.”
The immeasurable
There’s one thing else Troen has considered extra deeply because the October seventh assault: Israel’s management over Palestinian lives. His metropolis, Omer, is near the Israeli-occupied West Financial institution, and fewer than 30 miles from the Gaza Strip.
”The capability of 1 nation, nonetheless highly effective it’s, to completely suppress a motion of widespread resistance that’s deeply rooted within the inhabitants will not be an excellent file,” Troen says. ”Palestinians are going to want to acquire what they so desperately need, which is what we so desperately need, which is a state of our personal.”
Ilan and Carol Troen at their house in Omer, Israel.
Tamir Kalifa for NPR
cover caption
toggle caption
Tamir Kalifa for NPR
Ilan and Carol Troen at their house in Omer, Israel.
Tamir Kalifa for NPR
Troen calls it an older perception, beforehand extra summary to him, that turned extra pertinent after Oct. 7 and the times since.
”It is so palpable and visual,” he says. ”You are sitting in my home in the present day, which is a 45-second distance in flight time from Gaza by a missile. We might go downstairs, and I might take you to my bomb shelter — 16 inches of bolstered concrete.”
These are the measurements of an insupportable state of battle, alongside the immeasurable losses Troen’s household, and so many others, have endured these final 100 days.